14. Hero Differences

Even though there are a significant number of similarities between this works, Beowulf, Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, and The Canterbury Tales – focusing on the characters from Chaucer’s The Knight’s Tale and the Knight in the General Prologue; however, there exist inner immense dissimilarity. They are different types of heroes, each of them with their differences, representing the values of their culture. Furthermore, it is interesting that hundreds of years later, the definition of a hero is wholly exemplified in all of them.

The first and major difference is the way the main characters are portrayed: Beowulf, Sir Gawain, the Knight in Chaucer’s General Prologue and the characters in The Knight’s Tale, Palamon and Arcite. Beowulf is inhumane and fearless, which leads him to dangerous quests; while on the contrary Sir Gawain is more human – the poem frequently reiterates Gawain’s deep fears and anxieties. They both have true rigid morals yet Beowulf is arrogant, he lacks humility; Sir Gawain is always true and humble, his honour is his best value. Moreover, Palamon and Arcite, apart from being noble and young, they resemble Sir Gawain since they are equally valorous knights (Anderson, 1995, p. 125). Additionally, they may be classified as ‘courtly lovers‘ (Pope, 2001, p. 54). Regarding their narrator, Chaucer’s Knight is the example of the upper class: noble, humble, courageous and gentle -that is, a mixture between a warrior and a saint, very similar to Sir Gawain as well.

In his own way, each hero represents the values of his culture; they conveyed utterly different concepts of what a hero can be. Beowulf represents the Germanic warrior code: strength, courage, and loyalty. He displays his bravery in all stages of the epic; he embodies the qualities of a perfect hero in addition to being the bravest of all men. Sir Gawain and Chaucer’s characters – the Knight, Palamon and Arcite – represent courteysie and the chivalric code of the medieval period which also involves courage, loyalty, and physical prowess.

Whatever the circumstances, and whoever he deals with, Sir Gawain is always courteous, a term of complex meaning which includes most of the virtues recognized by medieval aristocratic Christian society as we see it in the poem. The courteous man is noble, religious, decent, graceful, eloquent, compassionate, humble, grave; he is capable of both love and chastity, frank in attitude but reserved in behaviour and aware of all the delicacies of personal relationship and public demeanour which go to make up the civilized life (Stone, 1974, pp. 19-20).

The knight who appears among the pilgrims in The Canterbury Tales, personifies fidelity and honour, has served worthily in “his lord’s war” and “has fought for our faith”. In conclusion, “the time-honoured ideal of knighthood, or chivalry, is explicitly emphasized” in Sir Gawain and Chaucer’s Knight (Borroff, 2011, p. 190). However, regarding Palamon and Arcite, a conflict between love and comradeship in the hearts of the two knights is the emotional focus of the story. It share the main concerns of medieval chivalry: tournaments, battles and romantic courtship. The main thing that distinguishes court romances is that “they present love in a particularly aristocratic and refined form sometimes called ‘courtly love’, and their violence is also of the highly ceremonial ‘chivalric’ sort” (Pope, 2001, p. 47).

Courtesy, and specially the courtesy of lovers, was part of the definition of the perfect knight. But the relationship of love and war is one-sided: honouring his lady confirms the knight’s courtesy, but it is most of all an excuse for the self-centered enterprise of demonstrating prowess. In practice, warfare remains the true test of chivalry, and courtesy is largely the stuff of courtly poetry (Wetherbee, 2004, p. 35).

Yet Sir Gawain and the Green Knight equally reflects its origin in the late 14th c., when the ideal of knighthood, based on the devoted loyalty of a mounted warrior to the feudal lord from whom he held land and for whom he fought, was slowly giving way to a les rooted military professionalism.

Furthermore, the heroes differ in the way they demonstrate their virtues.  Beowulf meets evil monsters which represent the antithesis of the warrior code:  Grendel, Grendel’s mother, and the Dragon. Sir Gawain’s test is not one against evil; it is one that tests his own integrity; he undergoes tests in order to prove his honesty, loyalty and chastity, and his allegiance to the chivalric code. Therefore, as the American scholar S. Greenblatt (2012, p. 184) points out, Sir Gawain is being measured against a moral and Christian ideal of chivalry.

We see him [Sir Gawain]at the crisis of the action forced to distinguish in scale of value the elements of his code, preserving his chastity, and his loyalty on the highest plane to his host; finally rejecting in fact absolute worldly ‘courtesy’, that is complete obedience to the will of the sovereign lady, rejecting it in favour of virtue (Tolkien, 1985, p. 4).

In terms of literature, undoubtedly this “break in the mathematical perfection of an ideal creature, inhuman in flawlessness, is a great improvement” (Tolkien, 1985, p. 5). We see the attempt to preserve the graces of ‘chivalry’ and the courtesies by mixing them with Christian morals. J. R. R. Tolkien states that the knight of the order of Chivalry “refuses adultery, places hatred of sin in the last resort above all other motives, and escapes from a temptation that attacks him in the guise of courtesy through grace obtained by prayer “(Tolkien, 1985, p. 5).

On the other hand, The Knight’s Tale is an example of a chivalric romance, or a tale of courtly love. In the tale, the knights Palamon and Arcite exhibit nobility, courage, and respect for their ladies fair, and the ladies exhibit elegance, modesty, and fidelity – that is, they stand for the values of courtly love, whereas Beowulf represent the Germanic warrior code, and Sir Gawain symbolize the values of Chivalry.

Themes , , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *